[back]

[Cute Anecdote] Definition of "definition"

What constitutes a good definition? In the era that modestly termed itself the "Enlightenment," some thinkers had the bright idea that the best definition of something was the shortest possible phrase that denoted that thing uniquely. This brilliant idea led to

man
1: featherless biped
and the title of a book by Woody Allen. My personal favorite by Baron Cuvier, quoted by Melville at the beginning of Moby Dick is:
whale
1: mammiferous animal without hind feet
(No, Moby Dick does not start with, "Call me Ishmael." The first chapter starts with those words, but there are two hilarious sections, titled "Etymology" and "Extracts," before the first chapter.)

In fact, the goodness of a definition depends on the context in which it is given: the previous knowledge that is assumed about the term being defined, the related terms from which it must be distinguished, the crucial qualities that need to be understood.


Michael J. O'Donnell <odonnell@cs.uchicago.edu>
Last modified: 20 January 1997